Category Archives: Brazil Gemstones

Siberian Amethyst, Debunking Another Myth of the Gem Trade.

by Richard W. Wise, G.G.

© 2010

ZambianAmethyst

A lovely example of Zambian amethyst, note the red flashes at 6 and 12:00 oclock. The alternating zones of purple and blue deliver a particularly velvety color

Quartz is as common as dirt.   At 12% it is the most abundant mineral in the earth’s crust and the primary component of ordinary dust.   Quartz is extremely stable and unlike other mineral components of the earth’s upper layer does not easily break down.

Amethyst is purple quartz, but despite the relative abundance of the mineral, exceptional fine rich purple amethyst, commonly called Siberian or deep Siberian color is extremely rare.  In Medieval times, there were two distinct varieties of gemstones bore the name. t Oriental amethyst, was actually purple sapphire and Occidental amethyst, the quartz gem that bears the name today.  Amethyst has seesawed in value over the centuries, today the finest of the fine might command $100 per carat at a high end jewelry store, in 1652, Nicols declared it to be of equal value to a diamond of the same weight.

I am not sure where the term Siberian originated and exactly how it became associated with the finest color in amethyst.   The usual reason why a specific locality gives its name to the finest quality of a given gemstones, (Kashmir sapphire, Burma ruby and Paraiba tourmaline)  is because the region is known to produce a particularly fine quality.  This is not the case with “Siberian” amethyst.  The fact is that for the past two centuries, the finest amethyst has come from Ceylon and Brazil (Streeter 1879)

Siberian amethyst is found in the Ural Mountains, with deposits outside the town of Mursinsk near the city of Ekaterinburg.  Amethyst has been mined in this area since at least the 18th century and probably earlier.  Sampling amethyst from mines active in this area in the 1830s, Gustav Rose, geologist with the famous Humboldt expedition (1837-1842) makes the following comment.  “The Mursinsk amethyst at times is very dark violet-blue surpassing that from Ceylon but mostly it is pale violet-blue (purple) or spotted and striped (zoned).”   John Sinkankas, who edited Rose’s text, calls this a “refreshing reappraisal” of Siberian amethyst and points out that Rose apparently held amethyst from Ceylon in the highest regard.    In 1900, the great German gemologist Dr. Max Bauer make the identical point adding only Brazil as a source of the finest examples of amethyst.  It is important to note that both these celebrated experts were able to view samples from actual working mines.  Other writers (Farrington 1903) identify Siberia as a major source for amethyst in the U. S. but this is contradicted by Streeter, Kunz and G-H Herbert Smith, whose popular Gem-Stones was, perhaps the most popular general book on gemstones in the 20th Century went through 14 separate editions between 1913-1972.

Up until the 1990s the primary world source for amethyst  were the Brazilian mines at Pau d’Arco, Rio Grande do Sul and Marabá. (Epstein 1988).   Pau d’Arco located in the Brazilian state of Para was discovered in 1979 and was known to produce a rich sometimes over saturated purple, which often exhibited the much desired red flash in incandescent light.  The other two sources produced a lighter brighter hued gem.  This writer saw large parcels of amethyst, often hundreds of carats, from all these sources available for sale in the gem market at Teofilo Otoni during this period.

In  the 1950s a new location of exceptionally fine gem material was located in Zambia in a  15 x 30 km belt, trending northwest in the Mwakambiko hills of the Mapatizya area of Zambia.  This material, a medium dark royal purple has become famous for its dark blue zones which add a velvety “royal” quality to the face up color much as a bit of purple does in the higher qualities of sapphire.  If one deposit were to be identified as the acme of amethyst it would be this one.

I was first introduced to the rough material in 1990.  Much of it was being smuggled into Nairobi, Kenya.  I had a good chance to examine the rough at that time and purchased several kilos.  The rough was a uniform deep purple of 80-85% tone with deep blue zones running through it.  Cut into gems it faced up with rich velvety slightly bluish purple and in incandescent light, the diagnostic red flashes and occasionally almost blue flashes of scintillation that are the hallmark of  deep Siberian quality.   Mining activity continues in Zambia but the major strike of exceptional material was mined out in the mid 1990s and a few gems cut from old rough are occasionally seen in the market.

Tourmaline: Copper, copper, whose got the copper?



You can’t smell it, you can’t taste it, you can’t see it but its presence or absence can make a difference of tens of thousands of dollars in the price of a tourmaline. What is it? Copper!

By Richard W. Wise

©2007


In late 1990 copper bearing tourmaline from Paraiba first entered the market. In 1991 I wrote an article for
Colored Stone “Tourmaline, A Modest Proposal” in which I predicted that just as Paraiba had established a tourmaline aristocracy, inevitably stones that exhibited the light to medium saturation and hue similar to Paraiba stones would escalate in price. What I did not anticipate and could not predict was the discovery of Paraiba-like-copper-bearing- tourmaline in Nigeria and Mozambique. (Pictured above left 0.88 Paraiba tourmaline from Brazil from the R. W. Wise collection.)

Prices have, indeed, escalated and the hierarchy has been established. Regardless of the quality of the stone, genuine Brazilian stones from the Paraiba mining region will bring the highest prices followed by Mozambique followed by Nigeria. (Pictured below right: 14.70 carat pair of pear shaped Mozambique cuprian tourmalines. Cutting Edge Award Winners, sold) Problem is, areas such as Afghanistan are producing vivid blue green non-cuprian gems that are superior to some of the cuprian stones. What determines the price, beauty, oh no, its all about the copper. We have become inured to such absurdities in the ruby, sapphire and emerald markets but Virgina its only a tourmaline! (pictured below left 3.97 carat Afghan non-copper bearing blue tourmaline from the R. W. Wise Collection)

So at every booth in Hong Kong showing a pretty blue green tourmaline. What was the first question? “Is it copper bearing?” Without asking that question is was impossible to price the stone.

Staggering Prices Differentials:

Price differentials can be staggering. The 14.70 pair of pear shapes pictured above right are certainly the finest of the Mozambique stones yet they sold at a price that was less than half what a comparable, if you could ever find a comparable, pair of Brazilian Paraiba stones would bring. Stones that compare in beauty but are not copper bearing bring hundreds of dollars while copper bearing look-alikes command prices into the low thousands of dollars per carat.

Whats New on our website:

Still haven’t given up my day job. Just finished uploading a number of new pieces to our online catalogue. Several new tourmalines plus sapphires and some lovely new and antique jewelry pieces. www.rwwise.com

Whats a buyer to do?

Follow me on gem buying adventures in the pearl farms of Tahiti. Visit the gem fields of Australia and Brazil. 120 carefully selected photographs showing examples of the highest quality gems to educate the eye, including the Rockefeller Sapphire and many more of the world’s most famous gems. Consider my book: Secrets Of The Gem Trade, The Connoisseur’s Guide To Precious Gemstones.


“Wise is a renowned author… He’s
done a marvelous job of this first book, monumental work, a tour de force…My recommendation: Buy this book”.


Charles Lewton-Brain, Orchid

whether you like to know what the best colour is in Tanzanite, or how to grade a Diamond, you will find it in this book. No other book I read before dealt with this topic is such detail as Richard Wise’s masterpiece.”

A. Van Acker, FGA
Amazon June 2005

“Secrets Of The Gem Trade: The Connoisseurs Guide To Precious Gemstones by Richard W. Wise is an impressive new reference for dedicated dealers and collectors of gems, gemstones, and … pearls. Introducing and descriptively exploring each and every gem covered in the easy-to-use reference, Secrets Of The Gem Trade contains an illustrated summary of each stone inclusive of its history and general information, hue and tone, saturation, which may be noticed as the finest, an understanding of the particular gems rarity, and the caution for synthetics and how to depict them, however depending upon the stone there may be description of clarity, color fading, multi-color effect, etc. Secrets Of The Gem Trade is very highly recommended to anyone interested in gemology as a superbly organized, authoritative, comprehensive, and easy-to-follow reference.”

Midwest Book Review
April 2006

Only $37.95. Read a couple of chapters online: www.secretsofthegemtrade.com.

Buy it on Amazon: www.amazon.com

Big Spike in Topaz Prices

















Mine Owners Manipulate Local Market

By Richard W. Wise, G.G.

© 2007

Collectors in the U. S. have noticed a substantial spike in topaz prices. Rumors have recently been circulating in the trade to the effect that price hikes were the result of forced closings of topaz mines by government environmental officials. I heard similar rumors from usually well informed dealers on a trip to Brazil in late January. (image: above left slightly orangy-pink Imperial topaz ring courtesy R. W. Wise, Goldsmiths)

According to David Epstein, author of The Gem Merchant and an American dealer living in Brazil the latest price increases are a result of market manipulation by the owners of Capão, Brazil’s largest commercial topaz mine. According to Epstein, Capao’s owners are systematically buying all the peach topaz produced by the 10-12 smaller mines currently active in the area in the topaz producing area. (image left: 0672 medium toned pinkish orange summer or ripe peach topaz from Capao Mine) Capão is located about five kilometers from the small village of Rodrigo Silva almost dead center of the two hundred ninety square kilometer topaz belt running in an east-west direction west of Oro Preto. (Image above: #2622 2.13 carat light toned pinkish orange spring peach topaz) For more on the Capão mine: http://Topaz; A Visit To the Mine

This buy up has been targeted at stones in the peach hues that the mine owners consider undervalued. Peach can be best defined as a pinkish-orange-brown to orangy pink range of hues. You will note that I do not use the term “Imperial” because the traditional distinction between precious and imperial makes little sense. Is an Imperial topaz not precious? Imperial is one of those terms that confuse rather than clarify. I like the terms spring, ripe and winter peach. A bit faciful? Yes, but fairly descriptive. As the orange tone deepens the stone goes from spring to ripe to overripe (winter), rotten would work but thats a hell of a way to market a gemstone.

The geographically limited production of topaz has made the market control scenario more than just possible. Commercial quantities of precious topaz ( all topaz other than the blue irradiated material), is mined in just one place, a twenty-square mile area in the Brazilian state Of Minas Gerais immediately adjacent to the city of Oro Preto. Capão is, in fact, one of only two large mechanized mines and the only one that currently sells commercial quantities into the world market. According to Epstein Capão’s owner Dr. Wagner and chief buyer Sr. Edgar have been aggressively buying up peach stones for more than two years.

Capão’s aggressive buying has born fruit. Prices in Brazil have jumped between two to three times previous levels. Oddly enough topaz prices in the higher priced pink, red and sherry colors have remained stable. According to Epstein, Capão’s principals believe that prices in these rarer categories are already high and they miners feared a falloff in demand if they attempted to push them higher.

Quick Review: The Gem Merchant, How To be One, How to Deal with One by David Stanley Epstein:

David Epstein’s The Gem Merchant has been out for several years but I have had a number of readers contact me for advice on how to become a dealer. Read this book! It is an excellent primer for those interested in entering the arcane world of the gem dealer. If you are interested in tax-deductible travel to exotic places, buying and selling beautiful things, read this book before you buy your first air ticket.

Mistakes made by neophyte gem dealers can be costly. David Epstein has been a practicing buyer’s agent in Brazil for twenty years and he knows whereof he speaks. This book will save you money.

“This book should be carefully read and digested, by those involved in buying and selling gemstones…”

Austrailian Gemmologist

Order direct from the book’s author
www.gembuying.com


Interested in reading more about real life adventures and secrets of the gem trade? Follow me on gem buying adventures in the exotic entrepots of Burma and East Africa. Visit the gem fields of Austrailia and Brazil’s famous Capao mine. 120 photographs including some of the world’s most famous gems. Consider my book: Secrets Of The Gem Trade, The Connoisseur’s Guide To Precious Gemstones.

“Wise is a renowned author… He’s
done a marvelous job of this first book, monumental work, a tour de force…My recommendation: Buy this book”.

Charles Lewton-Brain, Orchid

Only $39.95. You can read a couple of chapters online: www.secretsofthegemtrade.com.

Buy it on Amazon: www.amazon.com

Rockin in Rio

“Rio, when my baby smiles at me I go to Rio de Janeiro”

Arrived in Rio last Sunday night. Not long after my book came out in 2001 I received a letter from Hans Stern, 84-year-old founder of H. Stern the world’s fifth largest jewelry company. It was gratifying to know that a man like Mr. Stern had not only liked the book but had taken the time to write. “Next time you are in Rio, stop in and have a Café Zihno.” So taking the man at his word I called. Next thing I knew a car arrived and my wife Rebekah and I were on our way to Stern’s headquarters in Ipanema.

We spent an enjoyable hour as promised over Café zihno. For those of you who have never been to Brazil, Café Zihno is the national drink and is very much like Italian espresso. Mr. Stern may be an octogenarian but he still loves his job and is in the office every day

Mr. Stern brought out his personal gem collection, which included a carat plus Emerald cat’s-eye. I haven’t seen one so fine since 1987. He also showed us a tray containing several hundred carats of sherry topaz and an exceptional large red topaz from the Capao mine, the best I have ever seen. We topped it all off with a personally conducted tour of the Stern headquarters.

Lecture Series

I have been invited on this 2007 Regent (Radisson) Seven Seas World Cruise to deliver a series of lectures on gemstones. I have a grueling schedule that requires a 50-minute lecture about every three days. Other than that Rebekah and I are free to enjoy the many pleasures of the world cruise. Regent cruises are the last word in luxury, everything is included. With ports of call like St. Helena, Walvis Bay, Cape Town and Mombassa we will have little time to get bored.

St. Helena

Four days by ship out of Rio, we arrived sighted the island. St. Helena is a small island off the coast of West Africa. When Napoleon Bonaparte escaped from Elba the English, taking no chances exiled him to this small bit of volcanic rock, 500 miles from nowhere, after his final defeat at Waterloo. The former Emperor of the French spent his last six years on the island under the watchful eye of the British Army.

Originally discovered by the Portuguese, St. Helena was used for a refreshment station by Portuguese, Dutch and English ships navigating around the Cape of Good Hope. In those days, mariners often left goats and sheep and planted vegetables at places along their routes to reprovision other ships traveling that way.

The famous French Gem dealer and traveler, Jean-Baptiste Tavernier, the man who discovered what was to become the Hope Diamond, arrived on the island on February 8, 1649, twenty-two days out of Cape Town on a voyage from Batavia and noted the many lemon trees that grew on the island. Lemon juice, in those days, was the sovereign remedy for Scurvy, a disease caused by a lack of fresh vegetables.

We took the tour. Seems like you can see the whole place in about three hours. As to what the 6,000 or so present inhabitants on St. Helena’s 47 square miles is a mystery to me but the fishing is good.

Namibian Diamonds

Dateline: Walvis Bay, Namibia. Namibia, one of Africa’s “newest” nations, stretches 1300 km down Africa’s southwest coast, bordered in the north by Angola. to the south by The Republic of South Africa.

In 1908, a railway worker discovered the first diamonds in what was then the German colony of South West Africa. The discovery set off a free-for-all gem rush that ended only when the Colonial administration absorbed all private leases into one huge Concession, stretching the length of the country’s southern coast and some 100 km inland.

After the world war the territory became a League of Nations Protectorate administered by South Africa, which managed t
o hold onto the colony until 1990. Namibia has the richest marine diamond deposits in the world, with an estimated reserve of over 1.5 billion carats. All these deposits are secondary deposits meaning that the diamonds originally came from volcanic in situ deposits that were transported via the Orange river from South Africa and swept northward by the northwest current that runs just off the coast.

The average size of diamonds mined off the Namibian coast is a bit over ½ carat. A whopping 95% of these stones are gem quality.

Diamonds are responsible for 42% of all export earnings and 52% of government income and account for between 7-10% of the country’s GDP.

Mozambique Cuprian Tourmaline: Part II; Beyond the hype

Dateline: Hong Kong

Arrived in Hong Kong Monday night locked, loaded and ready to expose this Mozambique Cuprian tourmaline for the over-hyped fraud I thought it was and got a surprise. Quick answer to the burning question of the day; yes, there are some Mozambique stones that will stand up to the finest from Brazil.

Recently I have seen quite a bit of the stuff and found some of the asking prices bordered on the ridiculous. Examined one 7+ carat green tourmaline that looked like, well a medium dark yellowish green tourmaline, nothing special but the price. If it had been offered to me for $100 per carat I would have sent it back but it was Cuprian so the wholesale asking price was $3,500 per carat. (see part I, super star stone or overripe hype)

A lot of the Mozambique material out there simply does not make the grade. Yes you can find Caribbean aka neon-blue, aka windex-blue that is, a visually pure light/medium toned blue that is of the same hue as Paraiba but read the book www.secretsofthegemtrade.com; color divides into hue, saturation and tone with Paraiba and all its wannabes it is all about the saturation baby. Much of this material has a subtle gray mask, so subtle that you can’t actually see the gray; you just get the impression of cool and dull. This can be difficult to detect because blue is, generally speaking, a cool color. For collectors who depend upon laboratory reports rather than their eye to make a buying decision that can be particularly vexing but “buying the cert” has always been a snare and a delusion. So, if you need a certificate to tell you whether the stone is beautiful I suggest a new hobby.

How good is the best Mozambique compared to the Paraiba paradigm? On a scale of 1-10, the best of the Mozambique achieves a solid 8.5-9.0. I saw two stones that were 9+. So, is Mozambique over priced? The best, definately not but the common sort of pale material with current asking prices of several thousand dollars a carat is best avoided. Those who hope to ride on the coattails of a legend will be disapointed. Stones of this description are destined to fall from four figures to three.

Judging by Hong Kong, the price structure for very fine Mozambique Cuprian tourmaline is very much in place with little variation from dealer to dealer but overall the prices are half or less than you would expect to pay for comparable Brazilian gems.

Coming Up:

Big Price Increases in Fine quality untreated ruby and sapphire, are they for real?

Some experts are claiming 100% price increases in untreated fine quality ruby and sapphire. What’s the word from the Hong Kong Show? Stay tuned.